Brandon Personal Injury Attorney
It's Like Having a Lawyer in the Family
Follow Us Facebook Twitter Linked In

Call For a FREE Consultation Handset 813-438-5960 Serving Brandon, Tampa and all of Florida

Breaking Down The Contributory Negligence Defense In Florida


In one form or another, this defense appears in a large percentage of the car crash cases in Florida courtrooms. So, it’s very important to understand how it works and, more importantly, how to beat it.

Most insurance companies use this defense to shift blame for the accidents away from the tortfeasors (negligent drivers) and onto the victims. For example, an insurance company might admit that its insured driver made an unsafe lane change but say that the victim’s excessive velocity was the accident’s real cause.

Procedural and Technical Issues in Florida

Before a jury hears anything about multiple fault, a judge usually holds a hearing to determine if there is any evidence of contributory negligence. To return to the above example, the insurance company’s lawyers must prove that the victim was speeding and that infraction contributed to the Florida car accident in a meaningful way.

Many contributory negligence claims fail at this point. Typically, emergency responders only give citations to at-fault drivers. Unless the victim got a speeding ticket, there is probably little or no evidence of speeding other than the tortfeasor’s self-serving statement. The insurance company must also use weak, circumstantial evidence to establish the second point.

From a technical standpoint, The Sunshine State has one of the most victim-friendly contributory negligence laws in the country. Florida is a pure comparative fault state, so the judge divides damages only according to the jury’s division of fault.

Assume the jury finds that the victim and tortfeasor are each 50 percent at fault. If the victim’s damages were $100,000, the tortfeasor must pay $50,000. But in many other states, including neighboring Alabama, the victim would get nothing under these facts. Alabama is a pure contributory negligence state, so any contributing fault, no matter how slight, means zero compensation.

Some Variations on This Defense

Assumption of the risk is another blame-shifting defense in Florida that is a lot like contributory negligence. The elements of this defense are:

  • Voluntary Assumption: Not all liability waivers are truly voluntary. In fact, most of them are take-it-or-leave-it contracts of adhesion. The person must sign a non-negotiable waiver to participate in a particular event or activity.
  • Known Risk: This second element often comes up in passenger injury cases. People who get in cars with drunk drivers assume theoretical risks, but people who get into cars with drivers that swerve all over the road assume known risks. There’s a very significant difference.

The best way to defeat both assumption of the risk and contributory negligence is to stress all the positive habits that the driver exhibited. That way, the jury can clearly draw the line between “victim” and “tortfeasor.”

Count on Experienced Attorneys

Good attorneys should be ready for some common insurance company defenses. For a free consultation with an experienced personal injury lawyer in Brandon, contact Reed & Reed. We have four area offices (St. Petersburg, Lakeland, Tampa, and Clearwater).


Brandon Personal Injury
Reed & Reed, Attorneys at Law, is located in Brandon, FL and serves clients in
and around Brandon, Tampa, Apollo Beach, Sydney, Gibsonton, Balm, Valrico, Wimauma, Sun City Center, Lithia, Ruskin, Durant, and Hillsborough County.

Our Locations


101 East Lumsden Road
Brandon, FL 33511
Tel: 813-438-5960
Fax: 813-438-5995

St. Petersburg

1700 66th Street North, Ste. 104-1008
St. Petersburg, FL 33710
Tel: 727-362-7520
Fax: 727-362-7521


248 N Kentucky Avenue #72
Lakeland, FL 33801
Tel: 863-274-7715
Fax: 863-274-7716


401 E Jackson Street, Ste. 2340
Tampa, FL 33602
Tel: 813-440-6678
Fax: 813-440-6682


13575 58th Street N, Ste. 200
Clearwater, FL 33760
Tel: 727-767-9914
Fax: 727-767-9915


The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

No content on this site may be reused in any fashion without written permission from

MileMark Media - Practice Growth Solutions

© 2014 - 2020 Reed & Reed, Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved.
This law firm website is managed by MileMark Media.

Contact Form Tab